For over a century, the freak show occupied a strange and peculiar space in popular culture. Part curiosity, part cruelty, they were entirely mesmerizing. Under the canvas of traveling carnivals or on the wooden boards of Vaudeville stages, people with physical anomalies, rare conditions, or unusual talents were paraded around for entertainment. They were billed as “human oddities” or “living wonders,” often bearing cruel monikers and exaggerated back stories. Today, horror films and television shows continue to draw from the dark romance and disturbing legacies of these spectacles. Transforming real human lives into myth, metaphor and monster.
Real People, Real Stories
Before horror began to twist their images into fiction, these individuals lived very real and often, very heartbreaking lives. One of the most well known figures from this era was John Merrick, famously labeled as, “The Elephant Man.” Born in 1862 with Proteus Syndrome, a condition that causes severe deformities and overgrowths of various tissues, he baffled mid-19th century doctors. Merrick was displayed in Victorian freak shows across England. He finally found refuge in a London hospital under the care of Dr. Frederick Treves. His story, defined by isolation and exploitation would later be immortalized in David Lynch’s film The Elephant Man. A film that replaced gawking with empathy.
Another unforgettable figure was Schlitzie, often referred to as “Pinhead.” He toured the country with the Barnum & Bailey and Ringling Bros. circus. He was likely suffering from microcephaly and intellectual disabilities. Microcephaly is caused when a baby’s brain and head are significantly smaller than the rest of the body. These babies often develop sloping foreheads that look pointed at the top of the skull. Despite the disturbing way he was marketed to the public, Schlitzie was known for his sweet nature and love of music and dancing. He would clap when music was played. He would twirl with delight. Perhaps, that is the truest horror, not that he was different but that his gentle joy was turned into a spectacle. That a child’s innocence was framed as horrifying.
Daisy and Violet Hilton were conjoined twins born in England. They were joined at the pelvis and shared blood circulation but no vital organs. From birth they were treated less like children and more like possessions. Trained in music and dance, the twins became Vaudeville stars in the United States, sharing the stage with greats like Bob Hope and Charlie Chaplin. They drew massive crowds wherever they went. Yet behind the glamor was a darker truth, they lived under constant control, their wages stolen and personal lives restricted.
Then there was Johnny Eck, known as “The Half Boy,” a man born without the lower half of his torso. Eck embraced the sideshow, but also found success as an actor, magician’s assistant and artist. Johnny had a twin brother, Robert, who was fully formed. The two would sometimes perform together, using clever illusions to stage “sawing a man in half” acts that stunned audiences. Despite his fame, he preferred his quiet life in Baltimore, where he painted landscapes, built model trains and welcomed curious fans with charm and pride.
Grady Stiles, Jr. also known in the sideshow circuit as “Lobster Boy,” was born with ectrodactyly. A condition that fused his fingers and toes into claw-like shapes. Like his father before him, he was exhibited at an early age and became a popular attraction. Behind the scenes, however, his life was marked by alcoholism and violence. Though he used a wheelchair, his upper body was exceptionally strong and he often lashed out in drunken rages. In 1978, he murdered his daughter’s fiance but avoided prison because of his medical needs. Years later, after decades of terrorizing his family, he was killed in a murder-for-hire plot orchestrated by his wife and son.
Freaks (1932) Cinema’s First Real Sideshow
Tod Browning’s Freaks remains one of the most controversial and significant horror films ever made. Browning, himself a former carnival worker, cast real life sideshow performers in a twisted morality tale about cruelty, betrayal and revenge. The film features Schlitzie, the Hilton twins, Johnny Eck and others. It offers an unflinching look at the humanity behind the spectacle.
When it premiered, audiences were horrified. Not by the violence or the plot but by the mere presence of disabled bodies on the screen. Banned in the UK for decades and butchered by the censors, Freaks was dismissed as grotesque exploitation. Yet, at its core, it collapsed the genre, the so called “freaks” were the victims of cruelty and the so called “normal” people were the villains. Its infamous chant, “One of us! One of us!” has since become iconic, when it was once received as foreboding.
Horror Revives The Midway: American Horror Story: Freak Show
Decades later, Ryan Murphy would bring the freak show back into the spotlight with American Horror Story: Freak Show(2014). Set in a struggling Florida sideshow in the 1950s, the series drew heavily from Freaks and its real life inspirations. Characters were modeled after historic performers, Jimmy Darling, the “Lobster Boy” is a direct nod to Grady Stiles, Jr. While Pepper, with her distinctive look and tragic arc, is a clear homage to Schlitzie.
Unlike its predecessors, Freak Show made an effort to give its characters emotional depth and complex identities. They were not merely spectacles but people with desires, fears and inner lives. While the show still indulged in horror’s love of the grotesque, it also raised questions about who the real monsters were – the ones on stage or the ones in the audience.
Haunted Tents and Carnival Terrors: The Freak Show In Film and TV
The freakshow remains a recurring setting in horror, and for good reason. It offers an instant atmosphere of strangeness, a place where the rules of normal life don’t apply. In The Funhouse (1981), a group of teens is stalked through a traveling carnival by a deformed killer, merging slasher tropes with carny lore. Something Wicked This Way Comes (1983), based on Ray Bradburry’s novel, imagines a supernatural circus offering dark wishes at a terrifying price.
HBO’s Carnivale (2003-2005) presented a slow burning supernatural epic set against the dust and despair of a Depression era carnival. In Big Fish (2003), director Tim Burton conjured a dream-like world where the sideshow becomes a gateway into fantasy and myth. Even in non-horror films, the aesthetic endures: flickering lights, painted wagons, grotesque banners and the ever present echo of distant laughter.
Exploitation Or Empathy?
As modern creators continue to mine the freak show for atmosphere and metaphor, the question arises: can we tell these stories ethically? Horror is a genre built on fear, but it can also be a genre of empathy. The best stories pulled from the world of the sideshow, like Freaks and The Elephant Man, don’t mock or degrade. Instead they hold up a mirror to the audience, forcing us to defy our discomfort with compassion.
The real horror wasn’t the people in the show, it was the society that put them there. The freaks are not monsters. They are made monstrous by the way the world saw them, marketed them and most times, sadly, discarded them.
Final Curtain: The Freak Show’s Lingering Shadow
Though the traveling sideshows are all gone, their legacy lives on. In celluloid. In memory and in nightmares. Horror films and TV continue to pull inspiration from their rich troubled history. They are drawn to the emotional power of those long forgotten faces peering out from faded posters. Behind every banner that promised terror was a person, complex, often wounded and always more than the label assigned to them.
As horror movies move forward, the stories of the freak show still ask something of us. They challenge us to look beyond the surface. To question who the real monsters are. To remember that sometimes, the scariest thing under the tent was the audience themselves.